The 2006 NFL Draft is complete, and that means its time for all us yodelers to step up and give our marks and analyst on the draft. The draft definitely did not fall the way many us thought, but I can already name a few teams who are happy about that. This will be part one of our draft coverage where I will break down the first round of the draft.
1) Houston: Mario Williams became the first pick of the NFL draft on after signing a deal with the DE on Friday evening. This pick was a solid move and had us scratching our heads at the same time. Super Mario is a freakish defensive end who has the ability to make an immediate impact on any NFL roster. Yet, with the offensive talent available in this draft and Houston’s lack of offensive talent, it’s difficult to imagine a defensive playing going first. However people have to look at the Houston coaching staff to gain a further understanding of this pick. Gary Kubiak the former Denver offensive coordinator and current Texans head coach is a genius in getting production from underachieving RB’s (remember Ron Dayne’s Thanksgiving Day performance). Kubiak still see’s potential in the Houston offense, and the defensive needs of the team need to be addressed first. In the end Williams will be a good defender but in the long run Texan fans will grow impatient with the pick because it won’t equal instant wins on the field.
2) New Orleans: Reggie Bush, this pick was a no brainier. Once he fell into the Saint’s lap, they were obligated by the laws of nature to take Bush. Originally looking to trade out of this spot, there was no way they could have gotten equal value for that trade. The Saints have not so quietly put together an amazing off season. Drew Brees will be the starting QB and should be an upgrade from the inconsistent play of Brooks. Deuce McAllister will return to the Saints lineup next season after missing a year due to an ACL tear. Now the Saints have a powerful duo in the backfield that can play off each other. McAllister will not be ready to handle a full workload this soon from his injury, and Bush is an undersized back who never carried the ball more than 20 times at USC. Now the Saints can use him as a specialist and further exploit his explosiveness.
3) Tennessee: Vince Young. It had looked like the Titians were going with Leinhart with this pick because he is the more polished and will be immediately available to play. Young is ready to play now, but a year long apprenticeship would do him well. However it looks like he will not get that luxury. The Titians are looking to trade or release McNair to the Ravens before the end of the day on Monday. Looks like Young will be relying on his speed more than he anticipated this up coming fall.
4) N.Y. Jets: D’Brickashaw Ferguson. He was the best lineman in the draft without a question. While the Jets have questions at QB, they will have Pennington returning and he needs protection now. Ferguson can lockdown the left side of the line and with Adrian Jones on the other side of the line will provide Pennington the time he needs to make the plays down field. While not a sexy pick, it was a smart pick, and for once even Jets fans liked their picked.
5) Green Bay: A.J. Hawk. Hawk is an athletic outside linebacker who can make plays all over the field. The Packers defense was horrible last season; Hawk gives them a cornerstone to build around. Coupled with the addition of Charles Woodson in the secondary the Packers defense is slowly but surely rebuilding.
6) San Francisco: Vernon Davis. Davis is a freak of nature there is no other way to put it. At 6’3 250 pnds and a 4.3 40 yard dash he looks like a physical specimen out of comic book. That being said Davis is a legitimate threat on the field. He has the burst to stretch the field vertically, and the strength to go over the middle without fear. With very few offensive weapons available on the 49’ers roster Davis will quickly become a favorite target for second year QB Alex Smith.
7) Oakland: Michael Huff. This pick was a little odd. It originally appeared that the Raiders would pick a QB rather it was Young or Leinhart if they were available. Al Davis has always been a sucker for the star picks. However, Oakland did have a need to fill at DB. Charles Woodson moved on to Green Bay, and the young DB’s currently on the Oakland roster have performed at a sub-par standard to this point. Huff can play all over the secondary, he is ready to step in right now and start at CB.
8) Buffalo: Donte Whitner. A safety from Ohio State who will go down as the biggest stretch of the first day of the draft. The Bills have a ton of needs across the board on defense, and safety was definitely one of them, however it is doubtful that Whitner is the man for that job. He has poor instincts, and was often caught out of position. In a league where QB’s fake out camera men and professionals with their play action, a young safety who wants to fill the gap hard will struggle, and everyone knows when a DB is out of place on the field because it goes for seven.
9) Detroit: Ernie Simms. Finally the Lions appear to have gotten a first round pick right. After taking offensive players who have fizzled the last four years, Lions GM turned to defense picking up the linebacker Simms. Simms is an explosive tackler who had offensive players across the ACC scared to meet him head on. He also provides on the field leadership through his enthusiasm for the game. He will add a fire to the Lions that they have lacked for years now.
10) Arizona: Matt Leinart. This was a gift that fell into the Cardinals lap. No one thought Leinart would fall this far in the draft. (Especially Leinart look at his face when the Jets picked Ferguson). Leinart land in a great situation for him though. Being in Arizona keeps him close to the Left Coast that he loves so much. Also he will have the opportunity to play behind Kurt Warner who shows a lot of similarities in playing styles to Leinart. Also playing under a Denis Green system with talent at RB and WR around him will aid Leinart in his growth pattern. While Arizona had other pressing needs, this was the elephant in the corner that could not be ignored.
11) Denver (from STL): Jay Cutler. Denver traded up to get this pick, and came back with perhaps the best aggressive pick of the draft. Jake Plummer had a great season last year, but he is getting older, and his play as seen in the playoffs can be inconsistent. Cutler was one of my favorite prospects in the draft. He reads defenses very well, and he also has a Bret Farve gunslinger mentality, without all the arm strength. The current Denver system will fit him well, as Cutler likes to roll out and buy time.
12) Baltimore (from Cleveland): Haloti Ngata. The Ravens answered Linebacker Ray Lewis’s plea by picking up a big body to play the defensive line. Ngata has a huge frame that requires a double team just to move him out of a given gap. That will free up space for a roaming Ray Lewis, who played his best ball when he had the big Goose and Sam Adams in front of him.
13) Cleveland (from Baltimore): Kamerion Wimbley. Wimbley is a defensive end by trade who can play outside linebacker, and that is where he looks to lineup at in the NFL. Wimbley has great initial burst with lateral movement, and he will be a great athletic addition to the Browns 3-4 scheme. The Browns also signed Willie McGinest during the off season who will serve as a mentor for Wimbley in his early years in the league.
14) Philadelphia: Brodick Bunkley. Bunkley has great size, and will be able to fill out a starting lineup on the Eagles defensive line, that is looking to get bigger. He has great speed for an interior lineman, and has the ability to shed blocks and get up field. However, the Eagles have other pressing needs that were greater than D-Linemen. The Eagles are still lacking at offensive line and of course wide receivers. At least if the Eagles don’t pan out this season they cannot blame it on TO.
15) St. Louis (from Atlanta): Tye Hill. The Rams need help in their secondary. Last years second round pick Travis Fisher has not developed into the player the Rams hoped for. Therefore it is no surprise the Rams went defense with this pick. The surprise comes as to who it is. Jimmy Williams from Va. Tech, or Antonio Cromartie from FSU were thought to be better overall players for their respective positions, but both come with baggage. Williams has off the field issues, and Cromartie has injury problems. Yet, Hill already missed all of last season due to a knee injury. He is said to be healthy now, and ready to put in a full season of work. If that is the case he will be an immediate player for the Rams.
16) Miami Dolphins: Jason Allan. Allan is a talented safety who lost the end of his senior year due to a knee injury. If he is able to be bounce back from that he has the potential to be a great player in the NFL. He is a great open field tackler and shows a tremendous ability to play cover defense.
17) Minnesota: Chad Greenway. Greenway has been compared to Brian Urlacher on more than one occasion. He is slightly undersized, which becomes a concern as to rather he can hold ground against a heads up rush attack. Despite that, Greenway is excellent at reading keys, and has enough speed to often beat blockers to the point of attack. The term sideline to sideline definitely applies to Greenway. He is relentless in his pursuit of the ball, and will help sure up the weak side of what has been a bad Vikings defense for a long time.
18) Dallas: Bobby Carpenter: The Boys have had great success at drafting defensive players in the few seasons. Carpenter continues with that trend, but he is the wrong pick for the Cowboys. Dallas has immediate holes in their secondary where they lack a cover safety to help cover the hard hitting ability of Roy Williams. The Cowboys also need offensive linemen to replace the mammoth Larry Allen who was let go. Therefore OT Winston Justice or corner back/DB Jonathon Joseph would have been smarter picks. However in Carpenter the Cowboys get a fast linebacker who will fit their 3-4 schemes well. He is explosively quick, and gets up the field and after the QB.
19) San Diego: Antonio Cromartie. The Chargers have been in need of a DB for a while now. Too often in the past few season Charger DB’s have been burnt by average receivers. Cromartie has great size, and enough speed to quickly recover when he is caught out of position. Perhaps the most interesting aspect of this pick is the possible rift it widens between owner and coach. It is no secret that Marty Schottenheimer and GM A.J. Smith have butted heads over the handling of the QB situation and the dealing of Drew Brees. If Cromartie does not develop into the player they hope, this rift will continue to grow and may leave to Marty leaving.
20) Kansas City: Tamba Hali. Hali was a great defensive lineman for Penn State last season, but he will be overmatched in the NFL. The Chiefs have other pressing needs at DB and WR, so this pick is questionable. Hali was expected to be a late first round picks at best, but more than likely an early second round pick. Even at 20 this is early for Hali. Hali lacks ideal athletic ability.
21) New England: Laurence Maroney. Maroney looks to fill out what is already a two headed monster at RB. Last season the Patriots had trouble staying healthy at RB, both Dillon and Faulk suffered from injuries, and the Patriots went deep into their lineup to find help at that position. By picking up Maroney New England has the opportunity to groom him slowly and allow him to evolve into an NFL player, while playing alongside two great players.
22) San Francisco (from the Redskins) Manny Lawson. Lawson was often over shadowed by teammate and number one pick Mario Williams. However, Lawson should not be slept on. He is another player who can play both DE and OLB which is perfect for the 3-4 schemes San Fran is currently running. He is excellent at finding and taking the direct path to the QB. He has initial quickness that is deceiving and will catch many linemen and offensive players off guard. He will need to work on his down the field cover ability which will be new to him, but he his big enough to withstand the run.
23) Tampa Bay: David Joseph This pick came as a shock to me, as I did not have Joseph coming off the board till the second round. Not a knock against him as a player because he is a dominating offensive guard. He has quick feet, and can get down field, and also has the ability to trap block. However guards while not a dime-a-dozen are much easier to come by in the NFL. Offensive tackles are harder to create. They require more skill and have a greater responsibility as they often match up with the elite defensive players in the league in one-on-one situation. Again Winston Justice probably would have been a smarter pick.
24) Cincinnati: Jonathan Joseph. Joseph is a talented cover corner. He can play in the nickel scheme, and has the athletic ability to make recovery plays on balls he may have initially misjudged. The Bengals secondary was much improved last season with the improved play of Delta O’Neal. However he also had the benefit of feasting on NFC North QB’s. They need to continue to improve in the secondary.
25) Pittsburgh (from the N.Y. Giants): Santonio Holmes. Holmes is without a doubt the best receiver available in this year’s draft. With Randle El leaving in free agency, the Steelers where looking to add another threat at wideout. While they may have given up too much to trade up for this pick, Holmes will still workout well for this squad. Holmes has enough speed to stretch the field; he will also allow Hines Ward to move into the Slot position on third down plays where he can be a clutch receiver.
26) Buffalo (from Chicago): John McCargo. Once again the Bills have managed to leave us scratching our heads. Maybe Marv Levy is too old to be calling the shots. McCargo is an athletic defensive tackle with a great motor. That being said he is extremely undersized. He will have trouble holding his ground against the rush. When a DT has trouble with run, it creates a downward spiral on the defensive front couple that with a newly acquired DB who is prone to be out of position and it could be another long winter in Buffalo.
27) Carolina: DeAngelo Williams. This is a great pick up for the Panthers, who have become a master of using two RB’s for maximum potential. Stephen Davis is no longer a Panther and DeShaun Foster is the featured back. However as we saw in the playoffs Foster has trouble staying healthy. Enter DeAngelo Williams. Williams is an explosive runner, and since he will not be the work horse of the staff, he will have the opportunity to exploit his speed burst through the hole.
28) Jacksonville: Mercedes Lewis. Lewis fills the Jags need for a TE who is a threat down the field. Lewis can be a playmaker in the open field and over the middle. He will quickly become a favorite target of Bryon Leftwich. His blocking ability is still in need of development therefore Kyle Brady will still need to sub in from time to time.
29) N.Y. Jets (from Denver): Nick Mangold. Continuing to improve a shaky offensive line Nick Mangold will sure up the middle as a center. If D’Brickashaw Ferguson was the best linemen in the draft, then Mangold is without a doubt the second best, and it’s not often you get to say that about a center. Look for both Ferguson and Mangold to become staples for the Jets organization for years to come.
30) Indianapolis: Joseph Addai. As a running back at LSU Addai was great when he was healthy, which could be a problem for the Colts who already suffer from a lack of depth at RB? Addai also have the very large task of stepping up and filling the shoes of the departed Edgerirn James.
31) Seattle: Kelly Jennings. Jennings is the best available DB who does not come with the baggage of character issues. After letting Andre Dyson go the Seahawks needed to add depth to their defensive secondary. Jennings is fundamentally sound and rarely gets caught out of position, when he does he has enough athletic ability to quickly recover.
32) N.Y. Giants (from Pittsburgh): Mathias Kiwanuka. This comes as an odd pick due to the already established defensive ends that are in place for the Giants. Last year the Giants had the best D-End duo in the league. If anything this is a plan for the future pick, and the Giants look to groom someone who will be able to replace Michal Strahan, as he begins to age. Also have three great DE’s for pass rush situations cannot be a bad thing.